• 2 Posts
  • 26 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: July 8th, 2023

help-circle







  • Lol, Mr. Duncan does provide a very entertaining pop-history podcast don’t get me wrong, but please don’t go quoting him as a reference.

    I think you and I are arguing two different things, your source lumps together all the deaths during the Revolution, including Reactionary military actions while I am arguing specifically that very few people of the 3rd estate were killed extra judicially as a method of “terror” by the guillotine.

    Best of luck in your slow road to fascism. I hope you succeed in improving your lot with non-violent means. Maybe if the revolutionaries asked nicely Louis would’ve just enacted the Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen voluntarily.


  • Do you have a source for that claim? As far as I know most of the people guillotined were emigres or members of the upper class who went against the prevailing political party at the time.

    Many commoners did die in the Revolution, but they mostly died in the infernal columns or similar military actions in the Vendee region and other reactionary uprisings.












  • Your opinion is tainted by British and reactionary voices writing the history of the French Revolution.

    Overthrowing the Ancien régime left the average French person with much more political voice in the 1870’s than the average member of the 3rd estate could have hoped for at any point in the 18th century.

    -Wanton Murder

    Yeah there was violence political and non-political due to the anarchy that came from the revolution. This is unavoidable when the political elites do not respect the voices of the majority of their citizens.

    -Gave rise to an emperor

    Yeah because the entirety of Europe declared war on France several times in order to save their cousin king Louis, to save the estates of their rich noble exile buddies, then to avenge King Louis, and finally to protect British and exile monetary interests.

    -was mob rule led by a small group, not democracy

    It was eventually figured out, and it was always better than the pre 1789 status quo. **

    -did not materially change the lives of the majority of the French moving forward

    Lol, except for the entire political upheaval of the French Society.

    -was literally called the Reign of Terror

    It was called the Reign of Terror by British papers, the average Parisan had nothing to fear from the revolution other than reactionary mobs. Which was much safer than offending the wrong noble, or walking in front of the horse of some member of the gentry.

    I am basing the French Revolution from the Estates General of 1789 to the start of the 2nd French Republic.



  • That is not how Western cattle farming works. As someone in the industry I can confidently say that no cow sold to a processor get a majority of their calories through grazed uncultivated grassland.

    That is a feasible strategy for subsistence farming, but not in our for-profit farming model.