- cross-posted to:
- news@kbin.social
- cross-posted to:
- news@kbin.social
TOKYO (Kyodo) – Japanese animation art director Nizo Yamamoto, renowned for his background illustrations for numerous Studio Ghibli and other films,
TOKYO (Kyodo) – Japanese animation art director Nizo Yamamoto, renowned for his background illustrations for numerous Studio Ghibli and other films,
In my comment, I specifically accept their opinion that princess mononoke is one of the best movies ever made, I’m disagreeing with their assertion that the entire genre of animation peaked at the same time one of their favorite movies was made.
That’s completely ridiculous.
That’s like if you really liked The matrix and stated “you know what, movies peaked in 2000.”
If you read the count of monte Cristo and then said “books really peaked in 1844.”
No, they didn’t, you just like that thing.
Don’t make such a broad and absolute statement if you can’t deal with criticism.
There is no difference between saying Princess Monoke is one of the finest movies ever made and saying that animation peaked in the 2000s.
They are both examples of hyperbolic statements we all use to illustrate how passionately we hold our opinions.
The only difference between them is that you agreed with one and not the other, so it’s a bit intellectually dishonest to go into an emotional argument challenging exaggerated opinions as though they were true statements, particularly when you pick and choose which ones you decide to take literally.
If I’m wrong and you really did see the latter as a statement, it’s not a statement proveable by any metric which immediately makes you the easy victor and makes the other person look foolish.
At best it’s a cheap win but at worst, frankly, it’s unkind. It’s okay to just disagree; it holds no bearing on the validity of your own opinions.
There is a difference between saying you like the color red and saying colors peaked at red.
You’re right that an absolute statement is unprovable, which makes the claim ridiculous and overreaching.
As to your seemly defense of opinions, you all seem to split hairs on which opinions you take issue with.
I understood what you meant, but saying “no actually you just really liked that movie and haven’t found anything since” is presumptuous.
I’m capable of criticism - not sure what made you think I couldn’t handle discourse when all I said was “don’t put words in their mouth”
That is not what I said, and that is not what you said; both of your quotes are inaccurate.
Your wording of my quote is inaccurate and you made yours up completely.
You said: “Why try to overwrite someone’s opinion man :(”
I didn’t try to overwrite someone’s opinion, I agreed with their opinion on princess Mononoke and I’m correcting their overreaching comment that casually denigrates all forms and examples of animation before and after the early 2000s.
Why try to overwrite my opinion, man?
You literally just used the word corrected which is what I meant by overwriting.
Nobody needs you to “correct” them about their own fucking opinion
If OP is going to insult an entire genre of media, they should support their claim and be prepared for criticism.
I’m sure they appreciate your white knighting though.
As for you, make your mistakes, but don’t complain to others that they answer what you said rather than what you say you thought.