It’s good to be skeptical but I think they know what they’re talking about. It’s the forum for privacyguides which has been around since 2021, and previously as privacytools since 2015. Many of the people in the thread are active maintainers of the recommendations and knowledge base, where they apply a pretty rigorous set of standards. In fact, I think the only thing you can reasonably knock them for is being too cautious with new tools, but I think that’s a good instinct in this case, especially since you don’t really lose much by waiting to make sure something is legit and not a honeypot or flash in the pan
Lots of people recommending Mullvad which I have heard great things about, but worth noting it doesn’t have port-forwarding. If you’re doing any sizable amount of torrenting you may want to consider ProtonVPN which at least has partial port-forwarding support.